World Series MVP awards are often decided by the biggest moments, the biggest names, and the performances people remember most. But what happens when the numbers tell a different story?
I believe Aaron Ashby was the clear and obvious choice for World Series MVP, and I’m going to show you exactly why.
To make that case, I’m starting with one of the most important numbers in this conversation: championship win probability added, or cWPA. In simple terms, cWPA measures how much a player’s contributions change his team’s chances of winning the championship. It doesn’t just tell us what a player did. It helps show how much those contributions mattered in the context of winning it all.
That’s important because not every hit, strikeout, or home run carries the same weight. A home run in a game your team is losing 10–0 isn’t going to have the same impact on its championship chances as a home run that changes the outcome of a decisive game. Context matters, and that’s exactly why cWPA belongs in this discussion.
For this analysis, I removed players who finished the World Series with negative cWPA, along with those who finished at exactly 0%. That means Jake Bauers, despite his strong postseason, doesn’t make the cut with a -3.4% cWPA. Andrew Vaughn, Luis Lara, and Brandon Woodruff also fall outside this particular comparison.
Let’s start with the pitchers. Aaron Ashby is highlighted in blue because his cWPA wasn’t just the highest among Milwaukee’s pitchers. It was the highest of any player on the team.
Pitchers’ World Series cWPA
- Jacob Misiorowski — 12.8%
- Aaron Ashby — 15.4%
- Robert Gasser — 5.5%
- Abner Uribe — 11.2%
- Dustin May — 1.6%
- Trevor Megill — 3.7%
- DL Hall — 3.8%
- JoJo Romero — 0.8%
Read that again. Ashby finished at 15.4%, ahead of Misiorowski at 12.8% and Uribe at 11.2%. Every pitcher on this list made a positive contribution to championship win probability, but Ashby led them all.
Now let’s look at the hitters.
Hitters’ World Series cWPA
- Jackson Chourio — 3.7%
- William Contreras — 0.2%
- Brice Turang — 2.0%
- Cooper Pratt — 9.2%
- Christian Yelich — 1.1%
- Sal Frelick — 2.3%
Cooper Pratt stands out among the hitters, finishing at 9.2%. Contreras, the eventual World Series MVP, finished at 0.2% in this measure.
That doesn’t mean Contreras had a bad World Series. It means that, according to cWPA, his contribution to the Brewers’ championship probability was considerably smaller than Pratt’s and Ashby’s.
And that’s where this conversation gets interesting.
Let’s look beyond cWPA.
If championship win probability isn’t enough to convince you, let’s examine the underlying pitching and hitting numbers.
For pitchers, I’m using Fielding Independent Pitching (FIP), a statistic that focuses on outcomes a pitcher can largely control: home runs, walks, hit-by-pitches, and strikeouts. Lower is generally better, and a FIP below 3.00 is typically considered excellent.
For hitters, I’m looking at batting average, on-base percentage, slugging percentage, RBIs, and runs scored.
Pitchers: cWPA and FIP
| Pitcher | cWPA | FIP |
|---|---|---|
| Jacob Misiorowski | 12.8% | 3.01 |
| Aaron Ashby | 15.4% | -0.08 |
| Robert Gasser | 5.5% | 2.60 |
| Abner Uribe | 11.2% | 1.79 |
| Dustin May | 1.6% | 1.60 |
| Trevor Megill | 3.7% | 1.00 |
| DL Hall | 3.8% | 3.48 |
| JoJo Romero | 0.8% | 1.60 |
| Brandon Woodruff | 0.0% | 1.10 |
Hitters: cWPA and offensive production
| Hitter | cWPA | BA | OBP | SLG | RBI | Runs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jackson Chourio | 3.7% | .458 | .458 | .542 | 2 | 4 |
| William Contreras | 0.2% | .381 | .435 | .429 | 4 | 2 |
| Brice Turang | 2.0% | .316 | .435 | .474 | 2 | 3 |
| Cooper Pratt | 9.2% | .421 | .455 | .684 | 7 | 5 |
| Christian Yelich | 1.1% | .235 | .409 | .353 | 2 | 3 |
| Sal Frelick | 2.3% | .263 | .333 | .474 | 2 | 3 |
Statistics are from Baseball-Reference. FIP values and the historical comparison discussed below should be understood in the context of the supplied calculations.
Looking at the hitters, two names immediately stand out as strong candidates alongside Contreras: Jackson Chourio and Cooper Pratt.
Chourio hit .458, while Pratt hit .421 with a .684 slugging percentage, seven RBIs, and five runs scored. Pratt also finished with a 9.2% cWPA, substantially higher than Contreras’s 0.2%.
Contreras absolutely deserves credit for his offensive production. A .381 batting average and .864 OPS are outstanding numbers. He also contributed defensively behind the plate, something a comparison of batting statistics alone cannot capture.
But that’s the point: Contreras wasn’t the only Brewer producing at an elite level, and his offensive statistics alone don’t settle the MVP debate.
So if several hitters made significant contributions, and Ashby led every player on the team in cWPA, what exactly did Ashby do to separate himself from the rest?
Let’s talk about that FIP.
A negative FIP. Yes, NEGATIVE.
Jacob Misiorowski put together an exceptional World Series, and his 3.01 FIP reflects a strong performance. Relievers such as Dustin May, JoJo Romero, and Abner Uribe posted lower figures, although FIP can fluctuate considerably over small samples, particularly for pitchers who work fewer innings.
But look at Ashby’s number.
Aaron Ashby: -0.08 FIP.
A negative FIP.
If you’re wondering how that’s even possible, let’s break it down.
FIP is calculated using a formula that weighs home runs, walks, hit-by-pitches, and strikeouts against the number of innings pitched, then applies a constant. When a pitcher allows no home runs, limits walks and hit-by-pitches, and racks up enough strikeouts, the formula can produce a negative result over a small sample.
The math isn’t broken. The performance is simply unusual enough to push the calculation below zero.
And according to my historical research using Baseball-Reference, Ashby’s figure represents the only negative FIP recorded in World Series history.
Think about that for a second.
We’re talking about a statistic that has been applied to generations of postseason pitching performances. We’re talking about the World Series, where the greatest pitchers in baseball history have taken the mound. And Ashby produced a result that, according to that research, nobody else has matched.
Mariano Rivera is widely regarded as one of the greatest relief pitchers ever. Yet even Rivera never recorded a negative FIP in a World Series.
That doesn’t automatically make Ashby the MVP. No single statistic should decide an award on its own. But when a pitcher combines a historically unusual FIP with the highest cWPA on his team, the argument becomes much harder to dismiss.
Ashby wasn’t simply effective. His performance, as reflected in these numbers, was extraordinary.
History has a place in this conversation.
When someone accomplishes something unprecedented on baseball’s biggest stage, that achievement deserves serious consideration.
In 1956, Don Larsen threw the only perfect game in World Series history. He was named World Series MVP, despite a 2.18 FIP and four unearned runs in the series.
Larsen’s achievement was historic, and his recognition reflected the significance of what he accomplished.
Ashby’s performance is different, of course. A negative FIP isn’t the same thing as a perfect game, and no statistic automatically entitles a player to an award. But the comparison raises a fair question: how much weight should an extraordinary statistical achievement carry when we decide who deserves to be recognized?
For me, the answer is that it should carry a lot.
When I look at Ashby’s 15.4% cWPA, his -0.08 FIP, and the historical significance of that FIP result, I see a pitcher whose contribution to the Brewers’ championship deserves more recognition than it received.
Contreras won the award, and I’m not arguing that he had a poor series. He was an outstanding player on a championship team. But being a deserving candidate and being the most deserving candidate are two different things.
The numbers make my case.
And I keep coming back to the moment when Contreras brought Ashby up on that stage with him. I’d like to think it reflected an understanding of how much his teammate had contributed to the championship they had just won.
Because if you ask me who deserved to stand in the spotlight that night, one name keeps coming to mind.
Aaron… Freakin… Ashby.
Ian M. Ryan is a journalist from Oak Forest, Illinois. He follows high school, college, and professional sports.





